Free Printable Elf on the Shelf Squishy Toy Props

Grab these Free Printable Elf on the Shelf Squishy Toy Props! Dress your elf as a NeeDoh cube, butter, or dumpling squishy for a quick, easy elf setup tonight. Plus, find even more easy Elf on the Shelf ideas here.

Raise your hand if your elf is already running out of ideas. 🙋‍♀️ Same here, friend! That’s exactly why I made these free Elf on the Shelf Squishy Toy Props. They take about five minutes, and your kids are going to flip. Seriously, these squishy sensory toys are so hot right now.

What’s in This Squishy Elf Printable Set? 🧸

If you have kids, you know squishies are everywhere right now. These viral squishies fill toy aisles, TikTok feeds, and every school backpack. My two kids can’t get enough of them. So naturally, our elf wanted in on the fun!

This free printable set dresses your elf up like the most popular squishy toys. First, you get two different Elf Doh cubes inspired by the NeeDoh Nice Cube. Next, there are two Elf Butter wraps in blue and red that look just like a cube of butter squishy. Finally, you get two dumpling baskets with a red or green dumpling inside, with a basket that says Elf Dumpling. Honestly, the dumpling squishy version might be my favorite. 🥟

Why You’ll Love This Idea

First of all, this idea is fast. You print, cut, tape, and you’re done. There’s no glue gun, no flour mess, and no late-night store run (unless you are trying to score a coveted NeeDoh). We’ve all forgotten to move the elf at 11 p.m., right? This one saves the day.

Plus, it connects the elf to something your kids already love. A fidget toy they squeeze every day suddenly feels full of Christmas magic. ✨ It also works for every age. Little ones giggle at the silly costume. Meanwhile, bigger kids get the joke right away and think it’s hilarious. Perfect for tweens and even teens!

How to Use Your Elf on the Shelf Squishy Toy Props

Print Your Favorite Costume

Start by picking which squishy your elf wants to be. You don’t need to print the whole set at once. For best results, use white cardstock since it holds up better. However, plain printer paper works fine in a pinch.

Cut It Out

Next, cut around each prop carefully. Grown-up scissors give you cleaner edges than kid scissors. Want the props to last all season? Laminate them first, and you can reuse them next year too!

Dress Up Your Elf

Then, wrap the costume around your elf. Secure it with clear tape, double-sided tape, or your favorite removable adhesive. Skip anything super sticky, though, so your elf’s felt stays nice. After that, you’re ready to set the scene!

Shop Squishy Toys

Contains affiliate links for your convenience; learn more and see our full disclosure policy here. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

There are a lot of fun squishy toys for the holiday season. Some can be hard to find, but here are some ideas to help you get started. Click on each image to learn more. As these are viral some may go in and out of stock. Happy squishy hunting!

Fun Ways to Set Up Your Squishy Elf 🎄

Here’s where the fun really starts. For example, tuck your elf into a pile of your kids’ squishies. They’ll have to hunt for the elf hiding in plain sight! It’s like Where’s Waldo, but squishier.

Another idea is to let the elf bring a brand-new sensory squishy toy as a surprise. Set the Elf Doh costume next to a real Nice Cube with a little note. Something like, “I’m the original. Accept no substitutes!” Kids crack up every single time.

You can also throw a squishy party. Line up the toys on the kitchen counter and put your butter elf in the middle. Or set out ingredients to make cookies, but have your elf be the butter!

Variations for Using the Printable

Make It a Sensory Play Morning

Set out a tray with squishies, stress balls, and play dough. Then, add your costumed elf near the setup to watch. This sensory play setup gives kids a calm, cozy start to a busy December morning, great for the weekend.

Use It in the Classroom

Teachers, this one’s for you! Your classroom elf can dress as a dumpling and hide during reading time. Afterward, reward students with a quick fidget break. It builds excitement without any extra prep.

Create a Squishy Scavenger Hunt

Hide each costume piece around the house with little clues. Once kids find them all, the elf “transforms” into a squishy. For a big finish, hide a new Nice Ice Baby at the end. That’s a prize they won’t forget!

Common Questions About Elf on the Shelf Squishy Toy Props

Can Kids Touch the Squishies Near the Elf?

In most homes, the rule says kids can’t touch the elf. However, the toys are fair game! Just remind them to leave the costume alone so the elf keeps his magic.

What Paper Works Best?

Cardstock works best for these props. It feels sturdier and looks more like a real toy. Also, it holds up if you want to reuse the costumes next year.

Are Squishy Toys Safe for Little Kids?

Most squishies say ages 3 and up on the package. Still, always check the label before you buy. Keep an eye on little ones too, since squishies can tear if kids squeeze too hard (been there, done that).

Which Squishies Are Popular Right Now?

NeeDoh cubes, butter squishies, and dumpling squishies top a lot of wish lists this year. You’ll find them at big box stores and online. Bonus, they make perfect stocking stuffers! My best luck has been finding them at my local Walmart.

My Favorite Printable Supplies:

Contains affiliate links for your convenience; learn more and see our full disclosure policy here. 

• Printer: I love my HP Home Printer, it prints beautifully everytime no matter what projects I am working on.
• Paper: Depending on the durability you want with your printables, consider printing on white card stock or high quality paper.
• Laminator: For printables you are planning to use over and over again, simply laminate and use dry erase markers to mark up the printables.
• Paper Cutter: I love my CARL Paper Cutter. It makes trimming and cutting out printables a breeze.
• Sticker Paper: When printing tags or other free printables, sticker paper can make it easy to attach to gifts, boxes, or to make your own stickers.
• Cutting Supplies: You’ll want a great pair of paper cutting scissors and I love using an Xacto Knife for intricate details.
• Pens and Coloring Supplies: Here are some of my favorite writing tools for pencils and pens. Coloring supplies that I love to use in my own home: colored pencils, crayons, markers for adults, and markers for kids.

Download the Squishy Elf Printables Here

Please remember my printables are free for classroom use or personal use only. You may not sell or distribute the printable or digital file. If you wish to share the digital files, please refer friends to the link of this blog post where they can sign up to receive the free printable directly in their inbox.

Be sure to check your printer settings before printing, I generally make sure that the scale to fit option is selected to make sure all of the printables fit on the page.

To ensure emails for printables are received in your inbox add hello@thebensonstreet.com to your email contacts. Also check your promotions, updates, spam, junk or other folders if you do not see the email in inbox. Also for educators, consider using your personal email as many school districts block the emails or downloading of files.

Grab Your Free Printable! 🎁

Honestly, the best elf ideas are the simple ones. These Elf on the Shelf Squishy Toy Props take five minutes, but the giggles last all day. Your kids get a laugh, and you get an easy win. 🙌

So, what are you waiting for? Enter your email above to grab your free printable. You’ll also get my newest printables, recipes, and seasonal fun sent right to your inbox. Before you go, save this post to your Christmas Pinterest board so you can find it again. Happy elfing, friend! 🎄

More Elf on the Shelf Ideas:

• Elf Welcome Back Letter
• Elf Late Arrival Letter
• Elf Touched Letter
• Elf Christmas Eve Letter
• Elf on the Shelf Word Search Printable
• Elf on the Shelf Word Scramble Printable
• 25 Days of Easy Elf Setups with Printable Cards
• Elf Sized Breakfast Props
• Elf Sized Mailbox and Letters
• Elf Sized Pirate Props and Treasure Scavenger Hunt
• Taylor Swift Eras tour Elf Sized Props and Guess the Song Game
• Harry Potter Elf Sized Props and Word Search
• Detective Kit Props and Decoder with Clues
• Magician Set Props
• Art Studio Props with Drawing Prompts
• Elf Shopping Packages Props
• Elf Exercise Equipment and Challenge Cards
• Kpop Demon Hunters Props
• 67 Elf Printable Props
• Jail Props and Mugshot Signs
• Beach Day Elf Props
• Football Field Props
• Squishy Toy Props (Butter, Cube, and Dumpling)
• Check back again more coming soon!

Please pin this post for later and follow along on Pinterest: